BRENDAN WIMBERLY - Wednesday, November 14, 2012
Brendan ranks the US troops after the Americans eked out a draw on the match's final kick.

Jurgen Klinsmann took an experimental roster to face Fabio Capello's high flying Russians, and fittingly, the hosts were the real aggressors throughout the match.

The Americans were fortunate to walk away with a draw, and in the end, Klinsmann can walk away knowing that Tim Howard is still one of the world's best keepers - if only because he was tested so much.

Here's my take on how each American performed:


Howard - 9

An acrobat throughout. The Everton star delivered another spectacular game saving performance for the USMNT against one of the world's top teams. Would have been hard pressed to make a save on Feyodor Smolv's opening goal.


Fabian Johnson - 5.5

Johnson was good in stretches for the USMNT on the afternoon, but far too inconsistent. Helped infuse some life into the US attack with some nice dribbling displays, but also left Cameron and Goodson exposed on a few occasions when he lost possession.

Carlos Bocanegra - N/A
Injured in the 15th minute, not enough time to get an accurate rating.

Geoff Cameron - 6.5
Rescued the USMNT consistently in the first half. Brilliant job tracking back to deny Maksim Grigoriev an opportunity to make it 2-0 in the 19th minute. Dropped off slightly in the second half, including giving Russia a dangerous free kick in the 78th minute. Removed for Mikkel Diskerud in the 87th minute.

Timothy Chandler - 5
Came to life towards the end of the first half, looked dead towards the end of the second. Made nice runs up the right side and delivered a few quality crosses, but he was victimized defensively at times.


Michael Bradley - 8

Tireless performance rewarded with a spectacular goal. Bradley's volley from distance is sure to become a YouTube favorite and his marauding runs through the Russian midfield were, at times, the only offense the US could generate. However, this is partially due to the lack of service the forwards received, which Bradley and the rest of the midfield are accountable for.

Danny Williams - 3.5
An astonishingly poor performance for a player who had, in recent matches, established himself as a core part of Klinsmann's team. Time and time again, the Hoffenheim midfielder gave the ball away in terrible spots before his removal in favor of Maurice Edu in the 73rd minute.

Jermaine Jones - 7.5
Moved forward after Gatt and Gomez came off and helped link the American attack to the midfield. After a first half in which he, Bradley and Williams failed to connect with the forwards, Jones provided some tidy touches and clever passes which emboldened the US attack in the second half.


Herculez Gomez - 5

Largely anonymous. Granted, the US didn't do a great job getting their forwards opportunities in dangerous positions, but normally Gomez is able to overcome that with clever movement, and lots of it. Rarely found himself around the ball, and his one strong run in the box was overshot by Bradley. Removed for Kljestan in the 65th minute.

Jozy Altidore - 5.5
He's back, but didn't do much to enforce his hold on a starting job for the US. Worked hard up top, but service was lacking. Threatened the defense with a thunderous shot from 25 yards out which sailed just high, but also failed to control a brilliant opportunity created by Fabian Johnson in the 70th minute which would have seen him 1-on-1 with Russian keeper Vladimir Gabulov. Taken off for Terrence Boyd in the 87th minute.

Josh Gatt - 6.5
Good debut for the speedy winger. Found himself in dangerous positions in the first half when no other American could. Deserves kudos for providing some sort of attack early, but didn't stretch the Russian backline or take on defenders the way many would have hoped. Taken off for Juan Agudelo in the 63rd minute.


Clarence Goodson - 4.5

Replaced the injured Bocanegra in the 18th minute. Frequently found himself chasing Russian attackers from behind in the first half, and if it wasn't for Cameron, his poor marking could have been at fault for a few goals. Slightly improved in the second half before he gave away a silly penalty in the 84th minute.

Sacha Kljestan - 5
The Anderlecht player came on for Hercules Gomez in the 63rd minute and provided a languid performance. He provided a few nice passes upon arrival, but he fell into the background shortly afterward. His performance was capped with a cheap yellow card four minutes into stoppage time.

Maurice Edu - 4.5
Replaced Williams in the 73rd and was nearly as ineffective. Didn't provide the same terrible giveaways as his predecessor. Still the Stoke City man did little, if anything, to slow down the Russian attack as it hurdled toward the American net.

Juan Agudelo - 6.5
Provided the performance you would have hoped for from Gomez. Came on for Gatt in the 63rd minute and forced the Russian backline to work, providing constant movement and searching for seams in the Russian defense. Clever header back to the unrushing Bradley led to Il Marine's wonderful volley.

Terrence Boyd - N/A
Came on for Altidore in the 87th minute. Had few touches, one of which did set up Diskerud's equalizer however.

Mikkel Diskerud - N/A
Came on for Cameron in the 87th minute. Although his tying goal was fortunate to deflect off of a Russian defender, he took the chance well, driving a volley low and hard towards net. Optimism rewarded.
Wednesday November 21, 2012 4:25 am
Being in Belgium, I get to see Kljestan quite regularly. Is he worthy of a US team place? For Anderlecht he does a solid job of holding the ball up and getting in some good passes, but tends to lose the ball more than he should too.
Monday November 19, 2012 8:41 pm
Still don't get the love for Jones. He is a slightly more athletic version of Pablo Mastrioni and that is not a good thing. He is merely a yellow card waiting to happen. Pair Bradley with Williams and then put two speed guys on the wings. Enough with the garbage triple destroyer crap.
Friday November 16, 2012 12:27 am
Lets not over-hype Gatt, he looked lost the first 20 minutes of the game.
Thursday November 15, 2012 11:50 pm
@Termite, I agree with on the "commanding the box" question. I think the US keeper who did this the best was Friedel. Even Keller was inferior to Friedel in this regard. It was just a horrid giveaway by Williams though. I still don't understand what happened as "conclusions" drawn from the replays are speculative at best. As far as I can tell, he looked off balance and just didn't take a deep breath before putting it back into play. Bizarre.
Thursday November 15, 2012 6:57 pm
Against European competition, there has been a simple formula: Bradley in the line up = result. He has been that important. He has such poise in possession that he calms the whole team down and he can pass and he can shoot. If I didn't have a job, I'd go back and see why he was not effective the first 25 minutes or so. Maybe he kept having to adapt to Jones and Williams in his space?
Thursday November 15, 2012 4:35 pm
Granted, timmy made some "good" saves, but am i the only one who thinks he could have done better on the first goal in terms of coming out earlier and also reaction? and on the play that led to the PK? did he really command the box? could he have stepped up and smothered earlier? is that what Goodson was fruitlesslly waiting for before the reaction delay contributed to ackwardness ? did timmy shout him off?

he sits on his line too much for my liking but i admit i'm no expert
Cole Joseph
Wednesday November 14, 2012 11:57 pm
Just curious but how do Boyd and Mix not get a rating when they combined for the tying goal? I know they came on late but really?

Moving on I thought Chandler did well with a team he hasn't played with in awhile. We are going to be really happy we have him next year in the Hex.

Howard was a genius as usual. By far the most important USMNT player. Rough game for Williams but I am confident he will bounce back. Saw some other people on this site and on others bashing on Bradley, which is absurd. Probably the most creative player we can count on consistently. Even more so than Dempsey who I think is fantastic btw. Glad to see Altidore work hard but he looks like he is trying way too hard. I'm waiting for Boyd to get a run of games as the 1st choice striker. When he breaks out it will be in a big way. I thought Gatt did really well in his debut considering how good Russia is and the
environment. Nice job by Agudelo, if only he could find a team whose quality is somewhere between Red Bulls and Chivas USA. And finally Mix. About time he gets a game and look at the result. I thinks he needs to be with the first team here in out. You all know how bad we need a CAM. Lastly can we get a call up for JAB and Hines?

Email (will not appear on the site)


Join the YA Email Alert?

Comments are moderated and will be posted if they are on-topic and free of profanity, abuse and spam. HTML and links are not allowed.


Jesse Marsch has claimed a personal accolade as he's been named Coach of the Year in Austria.
American Trio Wins 3. Liga Title
Konrad Commits To Barcelona
Matarazzo, Stuttgart Eye Promotion
EPB Returns To Action In Austria