BRIAN SCIARETTA - Monday, August 31, 2009
Rich Schultz/WireImage
Is it time for Wynne to move?
This year is proving to be a good one in terms of evaluating domestically-based American players. The Gold Cup featured a bunch of young MLS players playing in their first international tournament at the senior level. Also this year, we have seen USA U-20 coach Thomas Rongen put together a team consisting largely of MLS and college players.

It has been clear that for some, a move overseas would be beneficial or even necessary to their careers.

There are a number of different factors in determining which players would benefit the most from such a move. Obviously, the first is looking at which players have the highest potential to succeed in the best leagues in the world. Also, it's important see which players are being held back by playing domestically.

While some players can have solid international careers and achieve their potential playing in the MLS, there are others that need to move overseas to keep improving. Finally, the players that most need to move abroad are players that have that ability but are also at a crossroads in their career. They are at a point where they have either outgrown the MLS, have been a poor fit in MLS from the start, or are even deciding where to begin their professional career.

So when looking at these factors, here are the players that stand to benefit the most in moving their careers overseas.

Stuart Holden (Midfielder, Houston Dynamo)

Stuart Holden is a player that now appears ready to head overseas and start a European career. Holden briefly tried to launch a European career at Sunderland after leaving college in 2005, but he returned to the USA after an incident in which he was physically attacked outside a bar in Newcastle.

The opportunity to make the move in 2009 or 2010 now looks more promising for the 24-year-old Holden. His improved play in 2008 and 2009 has paved the way for him to make consecutive World Cup qualifying rosters. His crossing ability is one of the best in the USA player pool while his shot and field vision are well above average. Right now, all indications are that Holden is the backup right-midfielder on the USA team behind only Clint Dempsey.

Holden has the ability to succeed in Europe, and such a move would only improve his game. His career in MLS has been one of constant improvement. This was most evident when Dwayne De Rosario left Houston and Holden was given more responsibilities on the field. With Holden a key part of their offense, Houston remains one of the best teams in the league. So while Holden keeps improving, it is only a matter of time before he outgrows the MLS.

Brek Shea (Midfielder/Defender/Forward, FC Dallas & USA U20 National Team)

If ever there was a talented young player that is falling victim to the inadequacies of MLS coaching, it is Brek Shea. He is an imposing presence on the field at 6-3 with a strong build, raw athleticism, and solid but unpolished skills. In MLS, however, coaches have been unable to even find a proper position for him. As a result, his development has been slowed and his play has been very inconsistent.

The good news for Shea, 19, is that that U-20 Coach Thomas Rongen wants him to be a big part of the World Cup team in Egypt. This could be the career boost that Shea needs because Rongen wants to move him into a more attacking role within the USA U-20 team.

History has shown that Rongen has done especially well at working with attacking midfielders and forwards at this age level. His U-20 teams have had players like Jozy Altidore, Freddy Adu, Sal Zizzo, Danny Szetela, Robbie Rogers, and Bobby Convey play very effective soccer at the U-20 World Cup. If Rongen can get Shea to play to the best of his ability in Egypt, there is a strong possibility that he will be noticed by European scouts.

Robbie Rogers (Midfielder, Columbus Crew)

Like Stuart Holden, Robbie Rogers had a brief tenure overseas that was prematurely cut short. After one year at the University of Maryland, Rogers left school to play at Heerenveen in the Dutch Eredivisie. Before getting to the first team, Rogers left Holland, reportedly because of homesickness, and returned to the USA. He has played with the Columbus Crew ever since.

It is clear now that a second try at moving abroad is almost a necessity for Rogers. At just 22 years old, there is little more he can accomplish in MLS yet he also has a lot of room to still grow. In MLS last year, he helped lead the Crew to its first MLS Cup championship and was named to the league's best XI.

Rogers' play at the international level has been uneven. In the 2008 Olympics and the 2009 Gold Cup, he showed quality moments but also long stretches of ineffectiveness. Playing in MLS is giving Rogers a chance to dominate opponents but also fall way short of reaching his potential. This is why he should move abroad.

Marvell Wynne (Defender, Toronto FC)

The 2009 MLS season will be Marvell Wynne's fourth season in the league. It has also been the season that has shown that for Wynne to achieve his potential, he should move overseas to a team willing to work with him to improve his tactics as well as a few other areas of his game.

In 2006, Wynne was the number 1 overall draft pick in the MLS Superdraft. His strength and amazing speed were the main reasons why he was so highly rated by scouts. More than 3 years later in 2009, he remains virtually the same player he was when he entered the league.

The reason why MLS hasn't been a good fit for Wynne is that with his raw athletic ability, he can often get away with poor positioning and ill timed runs. His speed easily allows for him to make up for these mistakes.

In May, 2009 USA national team coach Bob Bradley gave Wynne an important start in a World Cup qualifier on the road against Costa Rica. Wynne's deficiencies were badly exposed in this game which Costa Rica won 3-1.

Wynne's shortcomings are correctable over time with good coaching. Wynne is still a young player at 23, but a move does need to be made soon. There have been occasions where he has shown that his potential is very great, but in MLS he is never going to get close to the player he could be. Finding a well coached team in Europe that has an interest in working with him should be Wynne's highest priority at the conclusion of this MLS season.

Dilly Duka (Midfielder, Rutgers University & USA U20)

2009 has been an incredible year for Dilly Duka as he has come out of nowhere to emerge as one of the key components of the USA U-20 national team. Duka finished his second season at Rutgers University in the fall of 2008 and he received his first U20 camp invitation in January 2009.

Just two months later in March, he was the starting central midfielder and playmaker for the team in U-20 World Cup Qualifying. Shortly after leading the team to qualification, he announced he would not be coming back to Rutgers as he would seek to go pro. MLS league rules prevented Duka from signing with the Red Bulls this past summer, which means that heading into the U20 World Cup he will remain a free agent.

The U-20 World Cup will be an opportunity for Duka, 19, to showcase his talent. If he has a good showing in Egypt, he should seize any good opportunity to play overseas to develop his game. While he would be one of the top MLS draft picks next year, playing domestically would not be the best route for him. Since the MLS eliminated its reserve league at the end of the 2008 season, it has become increasingly difficult for young American professional players to play games domestically.

For a promising young playmaking midfielder like Duka, a combination of mediocre coaching and a lack of playing time would seriously harm his development. Duka should take advantage of any good European opportunity he gets after the 2009 U20 World Cup.

Ike Opara (Defender, Wake Forrest University & USA U20)

The 2009 U-20 World Cup will be a very important tournament for Ike Opara. It's been fairly obvious that he was going to use this tournament as a chance to earn a European contract since he announced in December, 2008 that he would not enter the MLS Superdraft and would remain in college at Wake Forest.

Had he stayed in the draft, he would have easily been one of the top picks, if not the number one overall pick. The decision to not go professional at that time has been seen as a move to play in front of top scouts at the U-20 World Cup while as a free agent, which would allow him to sign with any team without a transfer fee.

Opara, 20, would be wise to follow through with his chance to move overseas because he is one of the best centerbacks to play with a USA U-20 team in years. Given his talent and physical tools, he would have a chance of seeing first team action with a team in a solid league more quickly than most defenders his age.

The MLS isn't necessarily a bad option for Opara because MLS seems to develop young centerbacks better than it does young players at other positions, but if he takes advantage of a good opportunity in Europe after the U20 World Cup, he could emerge as one of the faster rising stars of USA soccer.

These players clearly stand the most to gain by moving their career overseas, and this fall will be a good chance for them to make their case.

Duka, Shea, and Opara will have the opportunity to impress scouts at the U-20 World Cup. Wynne and Holden will have the rest of the MLS season and possibly the remaining World Cup qualifiers to grab the attention of European clubs.

The January 2010 transfer window should see a few players on the list make moves, and next summer there should be a few more. While not all will move overseas in the foreseeable future, most of the players on the list will probably move by next summer.

The more players that do move, the better it will be for each of their careers. Each of these players has the ability to be a impact player for the USA national team and also for good clubs in strong European leagues.

The decisions each of the players make as to where to continue their careers over the next 12 months will largely affect how they develop over time. Finding good clubs in Europe to play for will be beneficial to both them and to USA soccer in general.
Wednesday September 2, 2009 12:09 pm
Well after this Summer, Stuart Holden has to be gone... he's just too good to stay in MLS, and at 24 he's old enough yet not too old... I'd hope he makes a mid sized club and not a very large one, see Adu about that.

Robbie Rogers has shown good One v One skills but so often has been muscled out of games, but playing on the left side is always a valuable thing no matter what the sport, he still needs to get tougher though.

Marvell Wynne always reminds me of Frankie Hejduk, great speed and work rate but less than steller touch... he's gotten by too much on his physical assets and must develop a better game or he'll just be spinning his wheels, albeit at a great speed!

As to the U20 players, they can't have failed to see what happened when Kenny Cooper wanted to move back overseas... I truly think that MLS/US Soccer have shot themselves squarely in the foot by trying to deny players their fair share of the transfer fee... either players will just play out their option year and leave or more likely from the U20 crowd, not even sign with MLS in the first place.
Wednesday September 2, 2009 10:43 am
Marvell Wynne is not good enough to move overseas and is I'm wondering who exactly would be "willing to work with him" when he's all speed and no skill. He looks like Jiminy Cricket and plays like he's on stilts. I don't get the hype - he's not even a good MLS defender so I'm not seeing a move anywhere except maybe to USL1 once people wise up.
Ed C.
Wednesday September 2, 2009 3:16 am
First, it sounds better with "the" in front of MLS. it works for NFL, as you said Evan but even the NBA. how about the NHL?

as for the coaching comment about arena - nice. i didn't know that. we go from one bad coach to another. US Soccer seems to be an old-boys network where our part time boss hires his buddies. why is rogen still there? he isn't even american yet they won't hire a foreign head coach! please dont' make him head coach of the nats!!!

there is a petition out there, i think its that should be signed! he's gonna hurt us next year at the world cup. i'd be happy even with sven goran than bradley! my high school soccer coach was much better than bradley, so maybe they can give him a call!
Wednesday September 2, 2009 2:49 am
Interesting article but I am tired of even the most talented writers calling MLS "the MLS". No one calls MLB "the MLB". The NFL makes sense because the National Football League is grammatically correct but the Major League Soccer isn't. Please stop.
Wednesday September 2, 2009 12:20 am
great article. we need real coaches especially for the MNT. Holden and winne are ready,Rogers has the talent but needs to get stronger. USA is the only team that went to the wold cup with a LACROSSE COACH(ARENAS)
Tuesday September 1, 2009 6:15 pm
@ Will - Sheanon Williams? how is that a glaring omission? He doesn't even have a club? Maybe there should be another article written about "players who think they are way better than they are and leave school because they think a slue of clubs want them, when in reality their heads are too big to realize its a little harder than it looks" - I think I'd read that article as well -

Good article, Brian.
Tuesday September 1, 2009 3:02 pm
Thank you for this informative article on potential rising American stars.

The USA would be well served, and could greatly help develop and bring forth its talent with youth academies modeled after those in countries like Holland.

The coaching in such academies is second to none in developing individual, and team skills, techniques, conditioning, match tactics and strategies. In other words; developing the fundamentals, and all aspects of what it takes to be an ultimate footballer.

USA football would benefit greatly at all levels from this type of coaching.
Tuesday September 1, 2009 12:23 pm
Inciteful and informative.Written by someone who obviously has a love for the sport AND his country.
Tuesday September 1, 2009 11:48 am
Fantastic content! Very useful and informative. Cannot wait to read more articles from you, Brian.
Tuesday September 1, 2009 11:25 am
Thanks for the fine summary and analysis. One is left to wonder how many other good players are held back by less-than-stellar coaching. There's something of a paradox for young American players -- do they need to have polished skills and a well developed tactical sense to attract interest in Europe, or are European clubs most interested in those with raw skills who can be signed cheaply and then developed quickly by better coaching? Finally: how can our coaching be improved? Should we be importing more youth coaches fom, say, the Netherlands?
Page 1 of 2
1 2  Next »

Email (will not appear on the site)


Join the YA Email Alert?

Comments are moderated and will be posted if they are on-topic and free of profanity, abuse and spam. HTML and links are not allowed.


The final stretch of the English league season is upon us, with several Americans on the verge of relegation with their teams.
Tale of Two Young Yanks in Europe
Wagner Nears Premier League Goal
YA lineup prediction vs. T&T
vom Steeg lands at Fortuna