CHRISTOPHER MCCOLLUM - Friday, July 22, 2011
The score read 4-2 in favor of Mexico, following a crippling second half performance by the U.S.'s southern neighbors. After several nearly disastrous performances leading up to the final, two early goals in favor of the Americans was a dream start.

At first, it seemed that the early injury of Steve Cherundolo might be countered by the second goal, giving breathing room for the much maligned Jonathan Bornstein who came on to replace the Hannover man, but four unanswered goals ended up being the flavor of the match. The roller coaster ride that was the American defense plummeted downwards at a rate of speed that left no hope for stopping, and according to reports from people at the scene of the slaughter, Bornstein was carrying himself with the disposition of a beaten man in a way that no television could convey.

There's not much surprise these days about how the U.S. National Team would almost be more preferred to play without a left back altogether, but at some point in time a solution needs to present itself. In a country with almost 25 million registered soccer players plus countless thousands abroad, one would think that there would be a halfway decent pool for every position on the field.

Despite the enormity of players, we've seen the stagnation of the American striker position over the past five years, and now the American left back for a similar length of time. Bob Bradley's various attempts over the years to fill the most gaping defensive hole have yielded largely unacceptable results, with no clear sign of change for the future.

Heath Pearce was a viable option for a short spell before a collapse in form bumped him down the pecking order, forcing Bradley's hand in eventually moving Bornstein up to the top of the list for a length of time that one commentator described as surely being "a result of blackmail." DaMarcus Beasley's experiment in the position came to a head with the Confederations Cup gaffe against Brazil that almost took him out of the player pool entirely.

Bradley has been on the hot seat lately for his team's underwhelming results, with media speculation running wild in June that he was set to be fired by Sunil Gulati. That was never really a strong possibility no matter how avidly certain large elements of the fan base wanted it. He has come under fire for seeming to favor his son and ignoring his erratic behavior that would suspend many other players, and for the overall lack of team cohesion and poor form. What he hasn't come under fire over enough though, is the seemingly discontinued search for a left back.

Members of the media and fans alike have been opining for years that the U.S. lacks a quality left back, so Bradley is stuck having to choose his regulars. It's almost as though Edgar Castillo was forgotten after the brief media love affair that was had only a couple short years ago.

Castillo was an exciting switch in allegiances at one time; after losing Neven Subotic and Giuseppi Rossi to Serbia and Italy respectively, it was a coup d`ètat to pull Castillo away from Mexico, and many thought he would fill the void that was attempting to be occupied by Bradley's choices. One substitution appearance for Michael Bradley against Denmark in 2009 was the only attempt Castillo got to make an impression, and apparently it was one so unfavorable that it couldn't change the status quo.

It's hard to believe that a player of Castillo's résumé, 127 appearances in five seasons in Mexico's Primera Division, can not get a longer look than half an hour as a makeshift midfielder, but with the catastrophe of the Gold Cup, Bradley is going to be forced to switch at least half of his back line to avoid being axed. Gulati wouldn't have fired him earlier in the month without a far more embarrassing Gold Cup, but if this abject failure of defensive stability doesn't improve in time for 2014 Qualifying - which is getting frighteningly close - the USSF President will be all but forced to find someone who can put the team in order.

The one immediate thing that Bradley can do is to bring Castillo back in the fold and try out the lineup in the next series of friendly matches coming up in September. It's probably too much to ask for him to be included in the lineup against Mexico on August 10, but Bradley does seem to have gotten a little bit more adventurous lately with his selections.

Either way, Castillo needs a roster spot, whether it be in August or September. The 24 year old has been loan hopping for a few years, but he still has value that could shore up the leak that Bornstein simply can not plug. A lack of consistent playing time with his club team lately should not be used as an excuse for Castillo, or anyone else for that matter, since Bradley has been picking a number of players who have been sitting on the bench for their clubs.

While we're making personnel changes to the back, there should be some personal changes as well; it's high time for someone to teach Eric Lichaj how to use his left foot. With a bit more seasoning and a consistently useable left, his experiment at left back could come to fruition, and provide an opposite field counter part to Timothy Chandler and Cherundolo.

Another interesting move for left back would be to throw 18 year old defender Sean Cunningham to the wolves, to see how he fares. He hasn't been getting much playing time in his short career at Norway's Molde FK, but the promise there is strong enough for legendary Manchester United forward and current Molde coach Ole Gunnar Solskjaer to recommend that he be given a trial at The Baby Faced Assassin's former club.

Young, rookie defenders don't typically get call ups to the national team, but when the starting left back is being beaten like a drum and the reserve left backs are all makeshift picks from different positions, why not? There's less than a year until the road to Brazil starts for the National Team, and there needs to be a solution to Bradley's woes.

Calling up an untested Cunningham or a forgotten Castillo should be no worse than keeping the status quo. Because currently, the status quo is going to jeopardize a spot in Brazil and also leave a "help wanted" sign for the USA head coaching job.
Mike E
Thursday July 28, 2011 8:44 pm
Okay, Bob is kaput, so who will it be? Lichaj or Castillo?
Thursday July 28, 2011 4:08 pm
Fortunately, much, not all, of what you said above is rendered irrelevant by the correct decision announced today that was at least 2-3 years delayed.

Castillo needs a longer look. You are correct: a 30 minute showing is outrageous and borders on incompetent decision making when the other option Bradley repeatedly turned to was Bornstein.

In fact it was insulting and if I were a Mexican/Latin fan of the US team, I would be angry and suspicious.
Wednesday July 27, 2011 7:43 pm
I like the Brek Shea idea, and I see Lichaj as depth at that position (and he was holding his own against Mexico, until he was moved to the right).

IMHO, the biggest mistake Bradley made in the Mexico gameis that he had a straight swap option. Did BB forget about Spector, who was on the depth chart as a right back, and plays in the EPL, as opposed to sitting on the bench (when he makes the bench!) in the Mexican Liga? Instead, BB brought-in arguably the biggest failure on the MNT in a decade (amongst players who were actually given a chance), and forced two positional changes along the back line, rather than swapping Cherundalo for Spector.
Wednesday July 27, 2011 1:36 am
Bradley has never been a good judge of talent, he doesn't have the technical skills to help a player improve, and he's a lousy tactician. Other than that, he's a wonderful coach and should have the job for life. Left back is always an issue for every team, club or national. If Eric Lichaj continues to play left back for his club team, their coaching staff should be able to speed his development. It sure won't happen with Bradley's tutelage.
Tuesday July 26, 2011 4:54 pm
yeah, i agree with Lorenzo. i would add Zach Lloyd as the second option behind Lichaj. Why didn't his name warrant a mention? Surely he has more to offer than Castillo!

Lichaj looked great against Mexico until Cherundulo went out and Bradley switched him.
Tuesday July 26, 2011 2:02 pm
In what world is an argument with a cable TV pundit that was so intense that it was reported THREE WEEKS LATER a suspendable offense?

You guys do good reporting, but you lose me with the drive-by Bradley bashing in these columns.
Tuesday July 26, 2011 1:23 pm
Why not Brek Shea? The guy can pretty much play anywhere on the field. He's big and skilled and getting better all the time. Personally I like Eric Lichaj there. He's shown the speed, toughness and skill at the international level, but I agree that he must improve his left foot. If he can do that, I think the position is his to lose. I feel at this time, left back is not our only problem on the back line. Aside from RB, where we have Cherundolo and Chandler, there are questions all along the line. I love our skipper Bocanegra, but how much longer can he hold his spot down? If he does, who will play along side him in the middle? We have a lot of up an coming youngsters developing, but unfortunately WC qualifying is nearly upon us. BB needs to get this defense worked out or we could be in big trouble.
Tuesday July 26, 2011 6:03 am
Since Bradley does not want to play him much in midfield why not Edu. He played center back at the Olympics. Convey has recovered form but Bradley does not give him a shot. Why not Beltran with Real Salt Lake.
Monday July 25, 2011 12:18 am
Why not play dolo' on the left and Chandler on the right. Chandler is Dolo's heir apparent and has looked incredibly dangerous on the right, while Dolo has the experience and decent left foot, which would give Lichaj the time to strengthen and develop at the position, while giving Sean Cunningham time to grow at club level.
Sunday July 24, 2011 12:13 am
Totally agree with Pancho about Castillo. He's barely sniffed the field on his last two loan spells, and he's he below average defender in a below average defensive league.

Sean Cunningham? How about letting him make a single professional appearance before we give him the responsibility of playing defense on the national team. Also, he won't be trialing at Man U, but rather training.

Hopefully Lichaj can hold down the job (which makes sense with Chandler as Cherundolo's understudy on the other side). Otherwise the pickings continue to look unbearably slim.
Page 1 of 2
1 2  Next »

Email (will not appear on the site)


Join the YA Email Alert?

Comments are moderated and will be posted if they are on-topic and free of profanity, abuse and spam. HTML and links are not allowed.


With Jesse Marsch and David Wagner at the helms of teams in the top flight, YA will cover their exploits this season.
YA Transfer Tracker
Yanks Face Relegation in England
Tale of Two Young Yanks in Europe
Wagner Nears Premier League Goal