CHRISTOPHER MCCOLLUM - Tuesday, October 9, 2012
Shockwaves reverberated through American soccer circles when Jurgen Klinsmann announced the roster for upcoming World Cup Qualifiers.

These shockwaves were in response to the omission of a player who has been riding a streak of superb club performances, earning plaudits from pundits both foreign and domestic.

It's Sacha Kljestan, right? Nope. Herculez Gomez? Nope. Michael Parkhurst? Nope. All three of those former cases of National Team neglect have been called into duty, though their stories at one time or another shared the same characteristics as the seemingly glaring omission of Jozy Altidore.

Klinsmann's roster to face Antigua and Barbuda and Guatemala features the shocking absence of the AZ Alkmaar sharpshooter who currently leads the Eredevisie in scoring. Altidore has been a regular feature on National Team rosters and in National Team lineups for years now, and his run of consecutive World Cup Qualifying appearances was far and away beyond his next best challenger on the roster.

Altidore has 23 goals in 42 league appearances for AZ, which is nothing short of remarkable for a young American striker on a foreign stage. His additional five goals in domestic cup and Europa League play are the icing on top, and his three assists this season have shown him to be a competent playmaker as well.

He has been logging consistent playing time under the same hardnosed coach that spurred Michael Bradley to great things, and though his work rate continues to be questioned at times, Altidore largely seems to have finally settled into a groove.

All of this success has kept him in Klinsmann's plans this year, allowing Altidore to keep his spot with the National Team. Just like Brad Friedel's streak ending this past weekend with Tottenham, however, this too was bound to come to an end. The key difference between the two though, is that Friedel's end was seemingly uncalled for, and Altidore's is seemingly wholly deserved.
It may seem like a shocking conclusion to reach, but statistics work in favor of it, and while statistics can be flawed, there comes a time when they need to be given some weight. The statistics in Altidore's case do not add up to him continuing to be a presence on the National Team. Going back to 2010, Altidore has played in 23 games for the red, white and blue, logging 1,462 minutes, or an average of 63 minutes per game. During that time, he has recorded four goals and three assists.

The numbers don't lie in this case. There are intangible benefits of having Altidore on the field, such as his ability to draw defenders and get the opposing team in foul trouble (though even that has been called into question recently), but his efficacy as a striker has been whittled down more and more. His scoring rate is a mediocre one goal every 365 minutes, and his assist rate is once every 487 minutes.

Taken together, Altidore is directly involved in a U.S. goal every 208 minutes since 2010, and his shot on goal average isn't much better, at one in every 132 minutes. It should go without saying that in order to be an effective forward, you should be making an impact on the offensive end of the field at much better numbers than those. Hitting one shot on goal every three halves is not a recipe for success.

It has been the case on multiple recent occasions that players who have been performing strongly with their club teams have been denied National Team call ups by Klinsmann, much to the angst of the fans and confusion of the journalists who try to make heads or tails of the often bewildering coach. Gomez was annihilating Mexican defenses and Kljestan was an integral part of a title winning team that earned a shot at the UEFA Champions League. Gomez's demons were exorcised months ago, and Kljestan has likewise seen a reversal of fortunes with this announcement.

These players have been a testament to Klinsmann's willingness to accept club success at face value, and to give them a shot on the National Team. It may have taken awhile, especially in the case of Kljestan, but the calls came. Shockingly, it's the same case with Eddie Johnson who has been an exceptional goal scorer with Seattle this season. There is no conspiracy here, and there probably is not even a grudge of some sort that may relate to a possible bone headed tweet from Altidore after Klinsmann criticised the forward's effort. It's simply trying to find the right players for the right games.

It didn't slip under the radar, but alarm claxons have not been ringing about Chris Wondolowski's exclusion from the roster, even though he too leads a league in scoring. He is coming close to breaking the MLS single season scoring record, has been exceptional this season and last, yet he has not shown enough in National Team camps to be given a shot at a higher stage. That's just the way it is sometimes, and that's the way it is appearing to be for Altidore as well.

The system employed at AZ benefits Altidore because he is the focus of the attack, and it also helps that Dutch defense is not up to snuff lately. His goals have been pictures of class, his movement off the ball has been great, but he works within a system that utilizes him the way he needs to be utilized. Klinsmann has too many other players worth considering to make Altidore the focal point, and as a result, Altidore slips down the pecking order because he either cannot, or simply has not, adjusted.

Perhaps this is the swift kick in the rear that Altidore has shown to sometimes need in order to get going. For too long he has been loafing around on the field wearing a U.S. jersey, seemingly held unaccountable for not showing up to play except on rare occasions. There are plenty of other players who have been guilty of the same thing for one or two games, but few outside of Altidore have been allowed to be unproductive in their position for so long.

Altidore has been outscored by Gomez, Clint Dempsey and Landon Donovan in 2012. That is not a bad thing, all three of those players are perfectly capable of finding the back of the net. But consider this: Altidore has the same number of goals as Bradley, Jermaine Jones, Carlos Bocanegra, Ricardo Clark and goal machines Michael Orozco and Graham Zusi.

Something's not right there, and though it obviously doesn't tell the whole story, this is the reason why Altidore has been left off the roster. Even though he's playing great for AZ, he has not played great for the National Team when given the same opportunities. Because of that, he is not getting looked over, disrespected, insulted, or screwed by Klinsmann. This is the difference between his case now, and the cases of Gomez and Kljestan. Those players were performing well with no National Team contact and earned a call up, while Altidore lost his call up because of continuous subpar performances for his country.

This is what's fair, and Klinsmann should be lauded for not keeping players around just because, even though they are regulars on the team. At least that's the case here- tackling the Maurice Edu situation will require an entirely different article.
Friday October 19, 2012 12:51 pm
Good article! One point of constructive feedback on this opinion would be that it ignores potential. Unfortunately for Jozy, he has been in the international spotlight since he was 18. So even though he has progressed over the past 3-4 years, he still isn't a star, he has to mature, and he has developmental items to work on. And the results/expectations placed on him as a teenager were likely unrealistic.

The reality is - Jozy is still 22 (1.5 year older than Boyd, and 9 months older than Corona). These two (chosen as the first I thought of, but no other specific reason) have yet to show Jozy's professional promise yet they would receive less criticism for inferior results since their future appears to be bright.

I would argue the article is a correct reflection of the past and current predicaments. Yet at 22, it is likely Jozy's best football is still ahead of him. And it is likely he is the best early 20s striker currently available for call-up. As such, he must be in JK's plans.
Thursday October 18, 2012 11:15 am
5 goals in two "worrysome" games.....2 by EJ and 1 assist by EJ.....Also, 2 by Dempsey who has struggled a bit when playing behind Altidore......I would have to say whether we like it or not (I know this was A&T and Guatemala), but it looks like Altidore has some splaining to do if/when he comes back
Wednesday October 17, 2012 11:59 am
Interesting article and there are a few points I agree with, but on the whole I don't think it was a good idea to leave Altidore off the roster. JK has always said that form and playing time will be a key ingredient to call ups and no one has had a better run of form for their league than JA. I do agree that JA needs to work harder on the national team but he is still a threat and gets other people open because of his combination of size and speed. I am very happy to see that we moved and played very well yesterday, I am also happy to see EJ finally doing well again, but neither EJ or Herc are as talented as JA and maybe this will be a wake up call (I sure hope it is), but if he is continually left off the roster it will hurt us in the long run.
Wednesday October 17, 2012 11:40 am
The fact JK is not taking the easy road impressive....which means he doesn't give a damn what we all think. He cud be out of a job tomorrow, and go back to his quiet life in LA and cud care less. He continues to search for players that can play his style and have the right attitude. And for a country that as recently as South Africa had NO BENCH, USA is still alive and has yet to put it's best 11 or at least the most senior 11 on the field, is amazing. If someone had posted by in June that LD would not have a goal and USA still moves on, we would have run him off the site
Tuesday October 16, 2012 12:24 am
Great article, great points, if JA was producing, there would be no question of him starting, under BB he was automatic choice, now he has to prove himself and stay at a high level nearly every call up. Great job and go Tigers!!!
Saturday October 13, 2012 2:13 am
I don't think that Altidore would have scored on either of EJ's headers. I do think he would have scored on both the opportunities that Herc screwed up. Klinsman has some tough decisions to make.
Friday October 12, 2012 9:32 am
Thank you Alex. Finally somebody with an unbiased, clear thinking head on his shoulders. Jozy has been hated on since day 1. The same things were said about Dempsey for awhile too. Its something with young, (over?)hyped players that people are quick to judge any deficiencies they might have. Its happened with ALL OF THEM.

@kicksNgiggles - how are you going to tell a player he has to integrate to Klinsmanns style of play when he plays a different style WEEK IN AND WEEK OUT for his club team? Extremely difficult for a player to adjust like that.

Its such BS that Jozy is being singled out on this issue. NO FORWARD HAS PRODUCED FOR US in the past 5-6 years to be honest. Its been a slew of guys that have given us a goal here and there.

We do not have a midfield that can consistently possess the ball. I still cant figure out what style of play Klinsmann is trying to implement with this team. He constantly harps about how he wants to take the game to the opponent. But every roster he announces seems to be setup towards the oppenents style of play.
Wednesday October 10, 2012 1:25 pm
This article is completely one sided. Nobody is saying that Jozy has been a stellar strike for the USMNT but who has? The real question is "Have the people that JK called in instead of Jozy demonstrated that they would bet better than Jozy for a make or break series of games?" I don't think the answer to that question is yes and that is why I think JK is making a big mistake. I am crossing my fingers that Herc stays healthy and this is all academic, but I would rather have Jozy in the line up if things go bad than Eddie or Alan.
Wednesday October 10, 2012 10:08 am
Brilliant article, and comments as well. Is this not what we all wanted? To have Klinsi come in and shake things up? For him to have "total control"? Altidore was a staple under BB and 9 times out of 10 he underperformed then as well. Paul is on the money. Altidore is lazy. He is big and strong and for the Nats he plays like a sissy. To agree with Paul again, if Jozy had anywhere near the work ethic of Gomez or Demps he would be scarey. His situation at AZ is easy for him. It fits his style. He has got to learn how to fit in on this National team. It would be a waste for him to fall by the wayside and not find a way to be an integral part of USA soccer. With that being said, if he does not or cannot adjust, I will not miss him. He has done nothing for us lately. Why waste a spot to someone who will work harder?
Wednesday October 10, 2012 9:36 am
Ok, so if not Jozy, then who? We've been struggling at the forward position for years now. I dont mind seeing EJ on this roster, but Herc hasnt done much either except run his butt off. Which is great, by the way, but its not getting different results. We have strikers and forwards scoring goals all over the world. Why is it that they cannot produce for the national team?
Page 1 of 2
1 2  Next »

Email (will not appear on the site)


Join the YA Email Alert?

Comments are moderated and will be posted if they are on-topic and free of profanity, abuse and spam. HTML and links are not allowed.


With Jesse Marsch and David Wagner at the helms of teams in the top flight, YA will cover their exploits this season.
YA Transfer Tracker
Yanks Face Relegation in England
Tale of Two Young Yanks in Europe
Wagner Nears Premier League Goal